Extreme Pizza
Pizza
Exclusive deals
These exclusive deals are only available to Restaurant.com members. Check back often as new offers are added daily.
Dining Discount Pass
Get discounts at over 170,000 restaurants and retailers nationwide.
Location and hours
Location
3100 Lakeville Hwy , Petaluma, CA
(707) 763-8100
Hours
More details
Reviews
Overall rating
(24 reviews)
I always get my pizza "to go", so I can't comment on the dining room which appears very casual. The staff are always super nice, pizza is delicious, many unusual varieties, never have a long wait. Extreme Pizza is terrific!
This is the 1st time I have been disappointed in the quality of the Pizza at EP. I usually really like it. But lasts nights Pizza was lacking something.
Very tasty! The AnnTony's Caribbean Sauce was great.
Food was great and so was the service
Food was fabulous!
Excellent overall...every time we have eaten there, however,As good as the lamb chops were, i was given only 2 & they were unbelievably small.For $29, i just could not believe the portion was so little.
Fast in and out for a take-out pizza.
Our waitress is always welcomingthe food is always fresh and deliciouswe enjoy this restaurant very much
great pizza and owner was very kind
The food is good, BUT. They are not good at taking directions. I always order chicken Yaki (Udon noodle) I ask for no celery, but extra carrots & broccoli. Otherwise I get a dish mostly full of celery and like 2 pieces of carrot & broccoli. Inevitably, the waitress appears to be taking notes to convey to the chef, but they never execute. And I get a plate full of celery and 2 pieces of carrot & broccoli every single time, like 10 times now. The food is really good, but this is annoying. And the service is so-so. I've also had trouble with take out, like getting no fried rice when I ordered & paid for it. These are easy corrections. Pay attention to your customers and you could improve to 5 (excellent).
Very good service and great fresh food at very reasonable prices.
Excellent food! Super friendly people, and great entertainment from the hibachi chef!
I had the filet. It was just so so. Some gristle and not very tasty. My husband had the lamb chops and they were out of this world. Yes, we will come back.
We ordered 4oz. New York steaks, which were very tasty, but about 1/3 of Ken's was grizzle and fat. Mine was better. I have no experience to relate to some of the following questions.
Great food, good wine, very friendly attentive server.
The best tasting Italian food I've ever had and the wait staff was very attentive and customer oriented. The restaurant was small and cozy with a nice bar on one side. We will definitely be returning!
Excellent attentive service & food. We have been going to Carrie Cerino's for over forty years
fast service, good food, great atmosphere!
fast service, good food, great atmosphere!
Pizza was very tasty and loaded with high quality ingredients.
Great service and very good food. Fish was very fresh. I like the restaurant dining area.
We have eaten at this establishment since it opened. We have been eating at this owner's other establishment since we were kids. Very unhappy with food quality and charges. House salad was always standard fare, but this time, our salad came out with just lettuce, and one grape tomato cut in half. No onions, olives, etc. Very upsetting. Kids were charged refills on fountain sodas. Our waitress was very nice. Meal quality for the prices charged was ridiculous. We have been long standing patrons, and will not be returning to this restaurant.
Very expensive!
Pizza was ready on time and tasted great!